Request an appraisal
A two-storey brick home on a tree-lined Ontario street

Guide · Understanding value

How an appraisal differs from an MPAC assessment and a sale price

Three numbers can describe the same Ontario property and still differ. Each one answers a different question, at a different date, by a different method.

Many Ontario homeowners have three numbers for the same property: the value in an appraisal, the assessed value on an MPAC notice and the price the property sold for. They seldom match, and the gap usually has a simple explanation. Each number answers a different question, at a different date, using a different method. Knowing which is which helps you use the right one and spot a real error.

What an appraisal measures

An appraisal is an independent opinion of value prepared by a qualified appraiser for a stated purpose, a named client and a specific effective date. The appraiser studies one property in detail, inspects it where the scope calls for it, and compares it with the market evidence most relevant to it. The result is tied to that purpose and date. A value for mortgage financing today and a value for an estate at a date of death two years ago can both be correct and still differ.

What an MPAC assessment measures

The Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC) assesses property in Ontario for property tax. It uses mass appraisal, which means it analyzes sales across groups of similar properties and applies the results to the recorded characteristics of each one, as of a common valuation date. MPAC's own guide explains how sales in your area feed into its assessments.

Three things follow from that method. The valuation date can be well before today. MPAC works from the property data it holds, which may not reflect a recent renovation or a change in condition. The model is also built for groups of properties, so a property with unusual features can sit above or below the pattern.

An assessment does its own job, which is setting the base for property tax. It is not designed to answer a lender's or an executor's question about one property at one date.

What a sale price tells you

A sale price is a fact. It is what one buyer paid one seller in one transaction. It reflects the market, and it also reflects the circumstances of that deal, including how long the property was listed, whether there were competing offers, the closing date, any conditions and how motivated each party was. A sale between relatives, a quick estate sale or a sale with unusual terms may not reflect the wider market.

An asking price and a realtor's comparative market analysis are different again. Both are pricing advice, prepared to help set a listing strategy.

Appraisers use sales as evidence. A single sale, even of the property itself, is one piece of that evidence and is weighed alongside the others.

Why the three numbers differ

When the numbers disagree, check these points before deciding one of them is wrong.

  • Date. An assessment uses MPAC's common valuation date, a sale happened on its own date, and an appraisal has its own effective date. In a moving market, the dates alone can explain a gap.
  • Purpose and method. Mass appraisal of many properties, one negotiated transaction and a detailed appraisal of a single property are different methods built for different uses.
  • Property data. Floor area, a finished basement, lot size and condition may be recorded differently in each source.
  • Terms and assumptions. A sale may include furniture, appliances or unusual terms. An appraisal rests on stated assumptions, which are set out in the report.

Which number answers which question

  • A lender deciding on a mortgage relies on an appraisal it has ordered or accepted, at a current date.
  • Property tax is based on your MPAC assessment.
  • An estate, a separation or a tax filing may call for a value at a specific past date. Your lawyer or accountant can tell you which value is needed and at which date, and an appraiser can then prepare it.
  • If you are selling, your realtor will advise you on the list price.

If a number looks wrong

Start with the facts. If your MPAC record shows the wrong size or features, raise it with MPAC, which has its own process for questions and reviews. If an appraisal contains a factual error, contact the appraiser with the page reference and the correction. Bring evidence, such as a survey, permits or a comparable sale the report did not consider, since evidence is what can change an analysis. Our guide to reading an appraisal explains where to look in the report.

Questions

Can I use my MPAC assessment instead of an appraisal?

That depends on who needs the number. A lender, a court or an estate's advisers usually want a value for their purpose at their date, which an assessment is not designed to give. Ask the party that needs the figure, and your lawyer or accountant where it is a legal or tax matter.

Will a new appraisal change my property assessment?

Not by itself. An appraisal is a private report for its client and intended users. MPAC sets assessments through its own mass appraisal process, and questions about an assessment go to MPAC.

Further reading

Start with a clear understanding of value.

Tell us the property and the decision it supports. Lenders and brokers can order directly.