Request an appraisal
Financial analysis documents on a desk

Residential and commercial · Assignment purpose

Independent review of an existing appraisal report

For lenders, investors, lawyers and owners who need an independent, written look at an appraisal report that another appraiser prepared.

Sometimes an appraisal report raises questions. A lender's underwriter may want an independent check before relying on it. An investor may be weighing a vendor's appraisal. An owner or a lawyer may think a report has missed something important. AREAS reviews existing residential and commercial appraisal reports and sets out, in writing, whether the analysis supports the conclusions.

What an appraisal review does

A review examines a report another appraiser has prepared. It typically asks whether the property is described accurately, whether the scope suits the stated purpose, whether the market evidence is relevant, whether the adjustments are reasonable and whether the conclusion follows from the analysis. The review report gives findings on each question in the agreed scope, with reasons. Canadian appraisal standards treat a review as its own type of assignment, with a defined scope and its own reporting.

What a review does not do

A review is not a fresh appraisal unless the scope says so. It does not automatically include a property visit or the reviewer's own opinion of value. It does not change, reissue or readdress the original report, which remains the original appraiser's work. A review also does not start from a preferred number. One that set out to reach a target value would be of little use to anyone who has to rely on it.

Defining the scope of the review

Every review starts with the question you need answered. Tell us why you want the review, who will rely on it and what concerns you. A specific point, such as comparables drawn from a different neighbourhood or a finished basement left out of the description, is more useful than a sense that the value seems low. From there we agree what will be examined, what data will be checked and what the review report will contain, before any work starts.

Reviewing residential and commercial appraisals

Residential reviews often focus on the property description, the choice of comparable sales and the adjustments made to them. Commercial reviews often turn on the income analysis: rents, vacancy, operating expenses, cap rates and discount rates, and the cash-flow assumptions behind them. AREAS brings more than 25 years of cash-flow modelling to that work, including DCF and Argus models. For income properties more broadly, see our commercial appraisals. AIC designations also matter here, because they set which property types an appraiser can sign for, as our guide to designations explains.

Sharing a report for review

Appraisal reports are prepared for a named client and intended users. Before you send us a report, make sure you are entitled to share it. If you are not the original client, check with whoever is. Send the complete report with all addenda, since a value page on its own leaves out the instructions, assumptions and evidence a review needs. Legal questions about using a review in a dispute or a negotiation belong with your lawyer.

What to have ready

  • The complete report, with all addenda and attachments
  • Confirmation that you are entitled to share the report
  • Why you want the review, and who will rely on it
  • Your specific questions, with page references
  • Records that bear on those questions, such as leases, plans or renovation details
  • Any date set by a lender, a transaction or a legal process

Questions

Will a review give me a new value?

Not necessarily. Many reviews assess whether the original report is supported without forming a new opinion of value. If you need a value of your own, say so at the outset, because it changes the scope of the assignment.

Can you review a commercial appraisal?

Yes. AREAS reviews residential and commercial appraisal reports. AIC's AACI designation covers any property type, while the CRA designation covers dwellings with up to four self-contained family units and individual undeveloped residential sites, so the reviewer's designation should suit the property.

Can a review be used in a dispute?

A review sets out findings on the support and reasoning in a report. Whether and how it can be used in a dispute is a question for your lawyer. Tell us at the start if that is a possibility, since it affects the scope and the reporting.

Further reading

Start with a clear understanding of value.

Tell us the property and the decision it supports. Lenders and brokers can order directly.