An appraisal report is built in a set order, with the question first, the evidence next and the answer last. Reading it in the same order is the quickest way to understand it and to spot anything that does not fit your situation. Appraisals in Canada follow the Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (CUSPAP), so most reports contain the same core elements, whether the layout is a short residential form or a long commercial narrative.
Purpose, client and intended users
Start on the first pages, where the report states why it was prepared. A purpose such as "first mortgage financing" or "estate settlement" defines what the value is for, and a report prepared for one purpose may not suit another.
Next, find the client and the intended users. The client engaged the appraiser. Intended users are the people the report names as entitled to rely on it. If you are not named, the report was not prepared for your use, even if you paid for it or were sent a copy. For mortgage reports, the Appraisal Institute of Canada (AIC) notes that a new lender usually needs a reliance letter, given with the original lender's permission.
Effective date and scope of work
The effective date is the date the value applies to. It is often the inspection date. For an estate it may be the date of death, and for a separation it may be a date your lawyer identifies. The report date, when the report was signed, comes later. Markets move, so a value at one date tells you little about another.
The scope of work describes what the appraiser did: whether the inside of the property was inspected, which records were reviewed, what market data was researched and which approaches were used. It also lists information supplied by others and relied on. If the scope is narrower than you expected, for example because access was limited, that affects how much weight the conclusion can carry.
Assumptions and limiting conditions
Read this section closely. Every appraisal rests on assumptions, for example that the title is clear, that there is no environmental contamination, or that the floor areas supplied are accurate. Limiting conditions set out what the report does not cover and how it may be used.
Watch for two kinds of special statement. An extraordinary assumption treats something uncertain as true, such as the size of a unit that could not be measured. A hypothetical condition treats something known to be untrue as true for the purpose of the analysis, such as valuing a house as if a planned renovation were finished. Both can change the value, and both should be stated plainly and explained.
The approaches to value and the reconciliation
The middle of the report holds the evidence. Look for the property description, the neighbourhood and market discussion, the highest and best use, and then the approaches used:
- Direct comparison, which compares the property with recent sales of similar properties and adjusts for the differences;
- Income, which converts the income a property can earn into value, by capitalizing one year's net operating income or by discounting a cash-flow forecast;
- Cost, which estimates the cost to build the improvements new, deducts depreciation and adds the land value.
Check that the comparable sales look similar to your property and that the adjustments are explained. In an income approach, check that the rents and expenses match the leases and statements you supplied. The report should say why any approach was left out.
The reconciliation comes next. Here the appraiser compares the results of the approaches, weighs each one by the quality and relevance of its evidence, and explains how the final figure was reached. A good reconciliation gives reasons for the weight placed on each approach.
The conclusion, read last
The final value often appears near the front, in a letter or summary, and again at the end. Read it last, once you know the purpose, users, date, scope and assumptions it depends on. Taken without those, a value is easy to misread.
Check the signature block as well. It names the appraiser and their designation from AIC and, for a Candidate Member, the Designated Member who co-signed. Designations explained sets out what each one means.
If something looks wrong, write down the page and the point. A wrong floor area, a missed renovation or a comparable sale that does not fit is specific and can be checked. Then contact us or the appraiser who signed the report. To compare an appraisal with your MPAC assessment or a recent sale price, see appraisal, assessment and sale price.
Questions
Can I ask the appraiser to change the value?
You can ask the appraiser to correct a factual error or to consider evidence the report did not include, such as a comparable sale or an improvement it missed. The appraiser will review it and explain whether it changes the analysis. A value is not adjusted to meet a purchase price or a loan amount.
Why does my report include assumptions I did not ask for?
Every appraisal rests on assumptions, for example that the title is clear or that information supplied by others is accurate. Standard ones apply to most reports. Any assumption specific to your assignment should be stated plainly and explained.



